Johnny Maestro’s. As lead singer of both The Crests and later The Brooklyn Bridge, he brought smooth melodies and heartfelt emotion to timeless hits like “16 Candles”and “The Worst That Could Happen.”He stood out for breaking barriers as part of one of the first racially mixed vocal groups in the 1950s. Over more than five decades, his rich tenor and warm stage presence made him a beloved figure on and off stage.
Johnny Maestro was born John Peter Mastrangelo on May 7, 1939, in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, New York City, one of three children of Salvatore and Grace Mastrangelo. He graduated from Charles Evans Hughes High School in 1956 and then attended Borough of Manhattan Community College. One of his main musical influences as a youth was singer Johnnie Ray, and he also loved doo‑wop groups such as the Harptones, the Flamingos, and the Moonglows.
Johnny Maestro began his music career in 1956 when he joined The Crests as lead singer. With them, he helped create one of the first racially mixed vocal groups in the music industry. Their biggest hit was the 1958 song "16 Candles,"which reached No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100. The Crests went on to chart several other hits like “Step by Step,”“The Angels Listened In,”and “Six Nights A Week.”
In the early 1960s, Maestro recorded briefly as a solo artist but did not find the same level of success. In 1968, he joined the Del-Satins and merged with another group, The Rhythm Method, to form a new band called The Brooklyn Bridge.
The Brooklyn Bridge burst onto the scene with their version of “The Worst That Could Happen”in late 1968. That song climbed to No. 3 on the Billboard pop chart and sold over a million copies, earning a gold record.
In the years that followed, The Brooklyn Bridge scored other popular songs such as “Welcome Me Love,”“Blessed Is the Rain,”“Your Husband, My Wife,”and “You’ll Never Walk Alone.”By the early 1970s, the band had sold more than 10 million records and became known for their strong vocal harmonies and horn-filled arrangements.
For over four decades, Johnny Maestro performed across the U.S. and Europe, appearing in arenas, theaters, and on television. After his passing in 2010, The Brooklyn Bridge continued to perform in his honor, with Joe Esposito stepping in as lead vocalist.
At the time of his death in 2010, Johnny Maestro's net worth was estimated to be around $124,000. He made his money mainly from album sales, live performances, and royalties from his music, and his family continues to manage his financial legacy today.